Post by Kate Band from me. Of course an animal can be humanely raised, with access
to natural grazing and foodstuffs, and not all cramped together in
some hangar. An animal can also be humanely slaughtered, where it is
stunned and unconscious before being killed. Yes I know there are and
have been abuses of this practice, as far as I can find out I do not
buy meat from such sources. In fact, even when it is not stunned
first, it can be humane: I meant it about the lamb - in a camp
half-way up Nanga Parbat we were greeted by friends of our hosts, one
of whom looked like all the pictures of the Good Shepherd you have
ever seen, with a lamb on his shoulders. After a bit he swung the lamb
down, talking gently to it, and cut its head off. That lamb led a
short but natural life on the hill and died instantly. In the
subsequent week we ate it all up. Of course this is not a defence of
halal killing in general, but to show that there can be a principle
behind slaughter that honours and celebrates the animal.
I don't understand the 'restrictive' bit at all. What's restrictive
about eating mostly vegetables, plus eggs and dairy, with the odd
piece of meat now and then? And no, we don't eat out these days
except at friends' houses and it would be rude to ask.
If you just don't like meat (which I gather from your sarcastic
'yum'), then by all means don't eat it, but just as you clearly resent
any 'theistic' aspects of the argument (not that I can imagine where
any god comes into it) so do I resent being preached at about the
moral turpitude of eating meat. Not getting at you personally, of course.